Magnesium Threonate vs Magnesium Glycinate (brain vs body optimization)
For brain-first goals (executive function, sleep architecture), choose Magnesium L-Threonate. For body-first goals (raising magnesium, muscle/nerve support) with good GI tolerance and value, choose Magnesium Glycinate. [2][4][1]
Magnesium L-Threonate has the best human signal for brain outcomes (small RCTs; executive function and sleep metrics) but supplies little elemental Mg and costs more. Magnesium Glycinate is the pragmatic pick for systemic magnesium optimization with solid tolerability and value. Many readers may combine: glycinate for daily repletion plus an evening split dose of threonate when targeting cognition/sleep—while staying within total Mg safety limits and medication timing rules. [2][4][6][8][1]
Magnesium L‑Threonate (Magtein) Products
Magnesium Glycinate (bisglycinate/diglycinate) Products
The Comparison
A Magnesium L‑Threonate (Magtein)
by Often sold as Magtein (patented)
Standardization: Typically 2,000 mg Magtein per day ≈ 144 mg elemental Mg
Dosage: 1,500–2,000 mg/day Magtein (≈ 110–144 mg elemental Mg) split doses
Benefits
- •Brain-focused: human RCTs show benefits on executive function in older adults with cognitive complaints
- •Sleep support in recent RCT (objective metrics via wearable)
- •Preclinical evidence for raising brain Mg and synaptic plasticity
Drawbacks
- •Low elemental Mg per dose—poor choice for correcting systemic deficiency
- •Costly per effective dose
- •Evidence base is small and often industry-funded
Safety:Generally well tolerated in trials; start lower if sensitive to headaches/drowsiness; follow drug-spacing guidance for Mg supplements [1].
B Magnesium Glycinate (bisglycinate/diglycinate)
Standardization: Chelated to glycine; some products are “buffered” with Mg oxide—check labels
Dosage: 200–400 mg/day elemental Mg (often divided)
Benefits
- •Systemic repletion: delivers higher elemental Mg per serving
- •Generally gentler on GI than many salts; good for long-term use
- •Broad clinical use across Mg trials typically at 300–400 mg/day
Drawbacks
- •No brain-specific human evidence vs threonate
- •Buffered versions may reduce tolerability/bioavailability
- •Still can cause GI upset at high doses or in renal impairment
Safety:Space from interacting meds (antibiotics, bisphosphonates); caution in kidney disease; heed upper limits for supplemental Mg [1].
Head-to-Head Analysis
Efficacy for cognitive outcomes (executive function, memory) Critical
Winner:Magnesium L‑Threonate (Magtein)• Importance: high
Sleep quality/architecture
Winner:Magnesium L‑Threonate (Magtein)• Importance: medium
A 2024–2025 RCT found Mg-threonate improved deep/REM sleep and daytime functioning vs placebo; glycinate has only general magnesium/sleep claims without glycinate-specific RCTs. [4]
Systemic magnesium repletion (body optimization) Critical
Winner:Magnesium Glycinate (bisglycinate/diglycinate)• Importance: high
GI tolerability
Winner:Magnesium Glycinate (bisglycinate/diglycinate)• Importance: medium
Bioavailability to the brain Critical
Winner:Magnesium L‑Threonate (Magtein)• Importance: high
Standardization/consistency
Winner:Magnesium L‑Threonate (Magtein)• Importance: medium
Threonate is commonly sold as the patented Magtein with consistent labeling (2 g→~144 mg Mg); glycinate quality varies and may be "buffered" with Mg oxide unless specified. [8]
Cost/value per effective dose
Winner:Magnesium Glycinate (bisglycinate/diglycinate)• Importance: medium
Per serving and per mg elemental Mg, glycinate is substantially cheaper; threonate products cost more and supply less elemental Mg. [10]
Availability and stacking flexibility
Winner:Magnesium Glycinate (bisglycinate/diglycinate)• Importance: low
Glycinate is widely available from many brands and easy to combine for total elemental Mg targets; threonate options are fewer and pricier. [10]
Which Should You Choose?
Executive function and working memory in mid‑ to late‑life
Choose: Magnesium L‑Threonate (Magtein)
MMFS-01 RCT improved composite cognition and executive function vs placebo; consider split dosing (AM/PM). [2]
Improving sleep depth/next‑day functioning
Choose: Magnesium L‑Threonate (Magtein)
21-day RCT showed gains in deep/REM sleep and readiness vs placebo; take part of dose 1–2 h before bed. [4]
Correcting low magnesium, muscle/nerve support, cramps
Choose: Magnesium Glycinate (bisglycinate/diglycinate)
Higher elemental Mg at tolerable doses and favorable absorption make glycinate the efficient repletion choice. [6]
Sensitive stomach or history of laxative effects
Choose: Magnesium Glycinate (bisglycinate/diglycinate)
Chelated glycinate is generally gentler than many salts at repletion doses. [7]
Budget‑conscious daily supplementer
Choose: Magnesium Glycinate (bisglycinate/diglycinate)
Lower cost per effective elemental Mg and broad availability. [10]
Safety Considerations
- Kidney disease: risk of hypermagnesemia—use only with clinician guidance. [1]
- Drug interactions: separate Mg by 2 h before or 4–6 h after tetracyclines/fluoroquinolones; separate from oral bisphosphonates; monitor with diuretics; long-term PPIs can lower Mg. [1]
- Upper limits: supplemental Mg UL is 350 mg/day for ages ≥9 y (does not include food Mg); higher intakes are used short-term in studies but should be supervised. [1]
- GI effects: any Mg form can cause diarrhea at high doses; glycinate is generally better tolerated. [7]
- Formulation notes: many threonate labels standardize 2,000 mg Magtein ≈ 144 mg elemental Mg; verify to avoid under- or over-supplementing when combining forms. [8]
- Medication timing and total Mg load matter more than form for safety; reassess if taking multiple Mg-containing products (antacids, laxatives). [1]
Common Questions
Can I take both threonate and glycinate?
Yes—if you mind total elemental Mg and drug timing. Many use glycinate for repletion and add threonate in the evening for brain/sleep goals. Stay within safety limits. [1][8]
Does threonate really cross the blood–brain barrier better?
Animal and mechanistic data support brain Mg elevation, and small human RCTs show cognitive/sleep effects; direct BBB imaging in humans is lacking. [5][2][4]
What dose should I start with?
Threonate: ~1.5–2.0 g/day Magtein split; Glycinate: 200–400 mg/day elemental Mg. Start low and titrate based on tolerance. [9][6]
Which is better for sensitive stomachs?
Glycinate is typically gentler than many salts at repletion doses; any form can cause diarrhea if you overshoot. [7]
Sources
- 1.
- 2.Efficacy and Safety of MMFS‑01 for Treating Cognitive Impairment in Older Adults—Randomized, Double‑Blind, Placebo‑Controlled Trial (2016) [link]
- 3.A Magtein (Mg L‑Threonate) + Phosphatidylserine Formula Improves Cognitive Functions in Healthy Adults (2022) [link]
- 4.Magnesium‑L‑threonate improves sleep quality and daytime functioning—Randomized controlled trial (2024) [link]
- 5.
- 6.Bioavailability of magnesium diglycinate vs oxide (human crossover) + Organic salts vs oxide RCT (1994) [link]
- 7.
- 8.
- 9.
- 10.