Suplmnt
Best supplements for hormone balance (perimenopause & menopause) hero image
Best Supplements for hormone balance (perimenopause & menopause)

Top 8 Evidence-Based Recommendations

Evidence Level: promising•Ranking methodology

We reviewed randomized trials and meta-analyses on 10+ natural options, prioritizing effect size, safety, dose practicality, and speed. This isn't affiliate fluff—just what actually moved the needle in humans [1][6][7][9][13][14].

Quick Reference Card

1.ERr 731 (rhubarb extract) — 4 mg daily — fast VMS relief [9]
2.Ashwagandha — 300 mg twice daily — stress/sleep + symptom gains [6]
3.Sage extract — 3,400 mg daily — fewer hot flashes in ~3 weeks [7][8]
4.S-equol — 10 mg daily — ER-β targeting for VMS/dryness [3][4]
5.Soy isoflavones — 54–90 mg/day (genistein >18.8 mg) — classic option [1]
6.Pycnogenol — 100–200 mg/day — VMS + vascular support [13][15]
Show all 8 supplements...
7.Melatonin — 0.5–3 mg nightly — improves sleep rhythms [16]
8.Magnesium glycinate — 200–400 mg nightly — calms the system

Ranked Recommendations

#1Top Choice

The quiet powerhouse for hot flashes—tiny dose, big relief

Dose: 4 mg once daily with food

Time to Effect: 2–4 weeks; improves further by 8–12 weeks

How It Works

ERr 731 is a rhapontic rhubarb root extract with estrogen-receptor beta–selective activity that modulates thermoregulation without stimulating endometrium; RCTs show reductions in hot flashes and anxiety with excellent tolerability. [9][10][12]

Evidence

In a 12-week RCT (n=109), ERr 731 cut Menopause Rating Scale scores and hot flashes vs placebo; anxiety also fell markedly [9][10]. Observational data (n=363) showed sustained MRS reductions over 6 months [11]. Preclinical and clinical safety support low risk at human doses; human trials commonly used 4 mg/day [12][16].

Best for:Frequent hot flashes/night sweats in peri- or early post-menopause, women avoiding hormones

Caution:Use caution with history of estrogen-dependent tumors; discuss with your clinician. [9]

Tip:Consistency beats dose escalation; take 4 mg daily at the same time—don't 'as-needed' dose.

#2Strong Alternative

Stress dialed down, sleep up—while easing climacteric symptoms

Dose: 300 mg twice daily (KSM‑66 or equivalent)

Time to Effect: 2–8 weeks

How It Works

Adaptogenic with GABA-mimetic and HPA-axis–modulating effects; in perimenopausal women, RCT showed improved MRS domains plus favorable shifts in estradiol, FSH, and LH vs placebo. [6]

Evidence

8-week RCT (n=100) in perimenopause: significant improvements in total MRS and MENQoL; estradiol ↑, FSH/LH ↓ vs placebo. Well tolerated. [6]

Best for:Irritability, sleep difficulty, stress-exacerbated hot flashes in perimenopause

Caution:May potentiate sedatives; caution with thyroid meds; start earlier in the day if vivid dreams.

Tip:Split 300 mg with breakfast and dinner; pair with magnesium glycinate at night for sleep synergy.

#3Worth Considering

Old kitchen herb, new clinical proof for hot flash frequency

Dose: Fresh‑leaf ethanolic extract 3,400 mg tablet daily (e.g., Menosan)

Time to Effect: ~3 weeks for noticeable change

How It Works

Mild phytoestrogenic and central thermoregulatory effects; trials show reduced hot-flash frequency and improved MRS vs placebo. [7][8]

Evidence

DB-RCT (n=80): 39% MRS reduction and 55% drop in hot-flash severity by week 4 vs placebo [7]; meta-analysis (4 studies, n=310) found significant reduction in frequency vs placebo. [8]

Best for:Hot flashes with daytime sweats; women preferring herbals with RCTs

Caution:Can be stimulating in high culinary doses; standardized tablets are preferable.

Tip:If you run warm at night, take in late afternoon to cover evening flushes.

#4

The 'active' soy metabolite—benefits even if you're not an equol producer

Dose: 10 mg once daily

Time to Effect: 4–12 weeks

How It Works

Binds estrogen receptor-β more than α, smoothing vasomotor symptoms without raising estradiol; works even in non-producers when taken directly. [3][4][5]

Evidence

Systematic review/meta-analysis supports hot-flash reduction with equol interventions [3]. RCTs using 10 mg/day showed improvements in MRS domains, libido, and sleep quality vs placebo. [4][5]

Best for:Women who don't respond to soy foods; vaginal dryness with mild VMS

Caution:If you have a history of ER+ cancer, review with your oncology team.

Tip:Take with a meal containing fat to enhance absorption.

#5

The classic phytoestrogen—works when genistein dose is right

Dose: 54–90 mg isoflavones/day, aiming for >18.8 mg genistein aglycone

Time to Effect: 6–12 weeks

How It Works

ER-β–biased modulation; meta-analysis shows meaningful reductions in hot-flash frequency (21%) and severity (26%) vs placebo; higher genistein content performs better. [1]

Evidence

2012 meta-analysis of 17 RCTs: reduced frequency and severity vs placebo; effect larger when genistein >18.8 mg/day [1]. Newer meta finds mixed global symptom effects but signals for mood/depression. [2]

Best for:Moderate VMS, mood swings; those open to soy

Caution:Possible interactions with thyroid meds (separate dosing); quality varies widely.

Tip:Pick standardized capsules listing genistein aglycone content; foods alone may be under-dosed.

#6

Circulation support that also cools the 'thermostat'

Dose: 100–200 mg/day (split)

Time to Effect: 4–12 weeks

How It Works

Improves endothelial function and lowers oxidative stress; multiple trials in peri-menopause report reductions in hot flashes/night sweats and better WHQ/Kupperman scores vs placebo. [13][15]

Evidence

DB-RCTs with 60–200 women showed symptom improvements vs placebo over 8–12 weeks; cardiovascular risk markers also improved in perimenopausal women. [13][15]

Best for:VMS with brain fog and cardiometabolic risk factors

Caution:May mildly lower blood pressure/glucose—monitor if on related meds.

Tip:Divide dose (AM/PM) to smooth 24-hour coverage of symptoms.

#7

Sleep first—your hormones follow a rhythm

Click to expand details...

#8

Calm the nervous system that amplifies hot flashes

Click to expand details...

Timeline Expectations

Fast Results

  • •Sage extract: relief by week ~3 [7]
  • •ERr 731: meaningful VMS drops by 4–8 weeks [9]

Gradual Benefits

  • •Ashwagandha: 8 weeks for full effect [6]
  • •Soy/equol: 8–12 weeks at adequate dose [1][3]

Combination Strategies

Cool & Calm Flash Stack

Components: ERr 731 (4 mg AM) + Sage extract (3,400 mg late afternoon) + Magnesium glycinate (200–300 mg 1–2 h before bed)

ERr 731 and sage both reduce hot-flash frequency via complementary ER-β/central effects, while magnesium improves sleep and lowers arousal that triggers nighttime VMS. Additive coverage across 24 hours. [9][7][8]

Take ERr 731 with breakfast; sage at ~4–6 p.m.; magnesium 1–2 hours pre‑bed.

Stress‑Sleep Reset

Components: Ashwagandha (300 mg twice daily) + Melatonin (0.5–1 mg nightly)

Ashwagandha improves MRS domains and hormonal milieu in perimenopause; physiologic melatonin restores sleep—together addressing two primary VMS amplifiers: stress and circadian disruption. [6][16]

Ashwagandha with breakfast and dinner; melatonin 30–60 minutes before bedtime.

Gentle Phytoestrogen Duo

Components: S‑equol (10 mg/day) + Genistein‑rich soy isoflavones (>18.8 mg genistein/day)

Both preferentially target ER-β; equol can help non-producers while genistein augments effect size. Useful for those preferring soy-based strategies. [3][1]

Take both with the largest meal for absorption; reassess at 8–12 weeks.

Shopping Guide

Form Matters

  • •Soy: choose standardized capsules listing genistein aglycone; aim >18.8 mg/day. [1]
  • •Equol: S-equol (not 'equol precursors') 10 mg/day. [3][4]
  • •Sage: fresh-leaf ethanolic extract tablets used in RCTs (3,400 mg). [7]
  • •Ashwagandha: root-only extract (e.g., KSM-66); avoid blends with stimulants. [6]
  • •ERr 731: look specifically for ERr 731 on label; most trials used 4 mg/day. [9][12]

Quality Indicators

  • •Third-party testing (USP, NSF, Informed Choice).
  • •Standardization to active compounds (genistein aglycone %, ERr 731 mark, withanolides %).
  • •Transparent COAs with heavy-metal/pesticide screens.

Avoid

  • •Proprietary blends hiding isoflavone content; skip if genistein amount isn't shown.
  • •'Hormone-free but estrogen-like' mega-claims without human RCTs.
  • •Soy/isoflavone gummies with <30 mg/day—usually under-dosed.
  • •Black cohosh claims of 'clinically proven' for hot flashes (evidence inconsistent). [14]

Overrated Options

These supplements are often marketed for hormone balance (perimenopause & menopause) but have limited evidence:

Black cohosh

Cochrane review found insufficient evidence vs placebo for hot-flash frequency or global symptom scores; heterogeneity and quality issues persist. [14]

Evening primrose oil

Systematic review/meta-analysis: severity may improve slightly short-term, but no benefit for frequency/duration vs placebo. [18][19]

Omega‑3s for hot flashes

Large RCT (n≈355) found no improvement in VMS frequency/bother vs placebo over 12 weeks. Great for heart health—not for hot flashes. [13]

Important Considerations

If you have a history of estrogen-sensitive cancer, abnormal bleeding, clotting disorders, or are on thyroid/anticoagulant/antihypertensive therapy, review any new supplement with your clinician. Separate magnesium/soy two hours from thyroid meds. Track symptoms weekly and reassess at 12 weeks.

How we chose these supplements

We prioritized human RCTs/meta-analyses in peri/postmenopausal women, then high-quality observational or mechanistic data when RCTs were sparse. Effect sizes, time-to-benefit, and safety drove rankings. Guideline context: NAMS 2023 does not recommend supplements for VMS due to inconsistent evidence; we highlight options with the best human data so you can discuss informed trials-of-therapy. [17]

Common Questions

What works fastest for hot flashes?

Sage extract and ERr 731 often show benefits within 2–4 weeks; ashwagandha typically needs 4–8 weeks. [7][9]

Can I combine these with HRT or SSRIs?

Often yes, but coordinate with your clinician—equol/soy and ERr 731 are generally compatible; ashwagandha may interact with sedatives/thyroid meds. [6][9]

Do soy or equol increase breast cancer risk?

Dietary soy is generally considered safe; supplement decisions should be individualized in ER+ history. Discuss equol/soy with oncology. [3][17]

How long should I trial a supplement?

Give 8–12 weeks at a proven dose before judging; track baseline vs weeks 4, 8, 12. [1][7][9]

Are supplements as effective as HRT?

No—HRT remains the most effective; these are for those who can't or won't use hormones. [17]

Sources

  1. 1.
    Soy isoflavones reduce hot flash frequency/severity: meta‑analysis of RCTs (2012) [link]
  2. 2.
    Soy isoflavones in climacteric women: 2023 meta‑analysis (2024) [link]
  3. 3.
    Equol decreases hot flashes: systematic review & meta‑analysis of RCTs (2019) [link]
  4. 4.
    Equol + resveratrol RCT improves HRQoL and specific menopausal symptoms (2016) [link]
  5. 5.
    S‑equol supplement reduces menopausal symptoms (Japanese RCT) (2009) [link]
  6. 6.
    Ashwagandha RCT in perimenopausal women (MRS, hormones) (2021) [link]
  7. 7.
    Sage extract DB‑RCT (Menosan) reduces MRS and hot‑flash severity (2021) [link]
  8. 8.
    Sage for hot flashes: systematic review & meta‑analysis (2023) [link]
  9. 9.
    ERr 731 (Rheum rhaponticum) RCT: efficacy vs placebo in perimenopause (2006) [link]
  10. 10.
    ERr 731 RCT: anxiety and well‑being improvements (2007) [link]
  11. 11.
    ERr 731 6‑month observational study (n=363) (2008) [link]
  12. 12.
    ERr 731 dosing/safety context (preclinical + human dose references) (2021) [link]
  13. 13.
    Omega‑3s ineffective for VMS: large RCT (2013) [link]
  14. 14.
    Cochrane: Insufficient evidence for black cohosh (2012) [link]
  15. 15.
    Pycnogenol RCTs in perimenopause (200 mg & 60 mg bid) (2013) [link]
  16. 16.
    Melatonin in peri/post‑menopause: randomized, placebo‑controlled (2001) [link]
  17. 17.
    NAMS 2023 Nonhormone Therapy Position Statement (2023) [link]
  18. 18.
    Evening primrose oil for hot flashes: RCT (2013) [link]
  19. 19.
    Evening primrose oil for VMS: 2024 systematic review/meta‑analysis (2024) [link]

This content is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice. Always consult healthcare providers before starting supplements. We cite research but errors may exist. Report an error