Suplmnt
Best supplements for menopause hero image
Best Supplements for menopause

Top 10 Evidence-Based Recommendations

Evidence Level: promising•Ranking methodology

We analyzed the highest-quality human evidence (systematic reviews, RCTs, and the 2023 Menopause Society guidance) across 40+ papers to rank what truly moves the needle—no affiliate fluff, every claim cited. [1]

Quick Reference Card

1.ERr 731 (4 mg/day) — best nonhormonal VMS relief in RCTs. [2][5]
2.S-equol (10 mg/day) — works even if soy never did. [4]
3.Sage extract (thujone-free) — fast drop in flash severity. [8]
4.Hops 8-PN (100 μg/day) — micro-dose, macro impact by week 6. [11]
5.Ashwagandha (300 mg BID) — stress/sleep relief that lowers MRS. [13]
6.Vitamin E (200 IU BID) — small but real flash reduction. [15]
Show all 10 supplements...
7.Pycnogenol (60–200 mg/day) — VMS + sleep/fatigue gains. [16][18]
8.Melatonin (1–5 mg HS) — helps mood/physical domains; mixed for sleep/VMS. [22]
9.Genistein-rich isoflavones — try food-first; effects vary. [6][7]
10.Soy+Hop combo — promising synergy; early data. [21]

Ranked Recommendations

#1Top Choice

The fast-acting VMS tamer most lists miss

Dose: 4 mg once daily (enteric‑coated), 8–12 weeks; first benefits ~2–4 weeks.

Time to Effect: 2–4 weeks for hot flashes; continued gains to 12 weeks.

How It Works

ERr 731 contains rhaponticin derivatives that act as selective ER-β agonists, modulating hypothalamic thermoregulation without stimulating uterine endometrium—hence VMS relief with a favorable safety profile. [2][5]

Evidence

Meta-analysis of 4 high-quality trials (n=390) found a clinically meaningful drop in Menopause Rating Scale vs control (MD −15.1; P<0.001). A 12-week RCT showed significant reductions in hot-flash number/severity by week 4 and better quality of life vs placebo. [2][5]

Best for:Bothersome hot flashes/night sweats when you want a nonhormonal, once-daily option.

Caution:Rare GI upset; data suggest endometrial safety, but avoid with estrogen-dependent cancers unless cleared by your clinician. [5]

Tip:Consistency matters—take with breakfast daily; judge at 8–12 weeks before switching. [2][5]

#2Strong Alternative

The phytoestrogen that works even if you can't make it

Dose: 10–40 mg/day; most RCTs used 10 mg/day for 12 weeks.

Time to Effect: 4–8 weeks.

How It Works

S-equol is a gut-derived metabolite of daidzein that binds ER-β with higher affinity than parent isoflavones, stabilizing the thermoneutral zone and reducing vasomotor spikes. Only ~20–30% in the U.S. naturally produce it—supplementing bypasses that bottleneck. [20][4]

Evidence

Systematic review/meta-analysis of RCTs showed significant reductions in hot-flash scores versus placebo, especially in equol non-producers; a multicenter RCT in non-producers (10 mg/day, 12 wks) cut hot-flash frequency ~59% vs 35% with placebo (p=0.009). [4][7][6][21]

Best for:Frequent VMS, especially if soy never helped you (likely an equol non-producer).

Caution:Generally well tolerated; discuss with your oncology team if you have estrogen-sensitive cancer.

Tip:Pick "S-equol" (not generic "isoflavones"); 10 mg twice daily can help smooth levels. [4]

#3Worth Considering

Sweat-switch support for flashes and sleep

Dose: Fresh‑leaf ethanolic extract ~3,400 mg/day (DER 1:17) or standardized capsules ~100–280 mg/day for 4–12 weeks.

Time to Effect: 3–4 weeks.

How It Works

Sage appears to normalize cholinergic and adrenergic tone and may affect central beta-wave activity, improving thermoregulation and perceived stress—an 'aha' for simultaneous flashes and wired-but-tired. [8]

Evidence

Placebo-controlled RCT (n=80) cut hot-flash severity ~55% and improved MRS total vs placebo within 4 weeks; earlier trials and registries support efficacy and good tolerability when thujone-free. [8][10][9]

Best for:Day/night sweats with tension and light sleep.

Caution:Avoid essential-oil/thujone-rich products; choose thujone-free extracts.

Tip:Once-daily tablets are easiest; pair with bedtime melatonin if sleep is the main pain point. [8]

#4

Tiny dose, big chill

Dose: Extract delivering 100–250 μg 8‑PN daily for 6–12 weeks.

Time to Effect: ~6 weeks.

How It Works

8-PN is a potent ER-β–preferring phytoestrogen from hops that modulates thermoregulatory neurons; may also support bone markers in osteopenic women when layered on Ca/D. [11][12]

Evidence

Double-blind RCT showed significant hot-flash score reductions vs placebo at 6 weeks (100 μg 8-PN). A 1-year RCT in osteopenic women showed favorable BMD trajectories with hop extract + Ca/D vs Ca/D alone. [11][12]

Best for:Moderate VMS when you prefer micro-dosing and once-daily capsules.

Caution:Possible drug interactions via phytoestrogen pathways; avoid with estrogen-sensitive cancers unless cleared.

Tip:Look for quantified 8-PN on the label; more isn't always better—the 100 μg dose outperformed 250 μg in one trial. [11]

#5

Calm the system, quiet the sweats

Dose: 300 mg root extract (e.g., KSM‑66) twice daily for 8 weeks.

Time to Effect: 4–8 weeks.

How It Works

Adaptogenic modulation of HPA axis and GABAergic tone can lower perceived stress and improve sleep—both amplify VMS. Some data show small shifts in estradiol/FSH consistent with symptom relief. [13]

Evidence

8-week RCT (n=100) significantly improved Menopause Rating Scale, MENQOL, and hot-flash scores vs placebo; also showed increased estradiol and lower FSH/LH within physiologic ranges. [13]

Best for:Perimenopausal irritability, sleep fragmentation, stress-linked VMS.

Caution:Sedation in some; avoid with hyperthyroidism or sedatives unless supervised.

Tip:Take with breakfast and dinner; if sedating, move evening dose to 60–90 min before bed. [13]

#6

Small, safe nudge for flashes

Dose: 200 IU twice daily for 8 weeks.

Time to Effect: 2–4 weeks.

How It Works

Antioxidant modulation may soften vasomotor reactivity; effect size is modest but meaningful for some. [15]

Evidence

Triple-blind RCT (n=84) found vitamin E reduced hot-flash counts by nearly one-third vs placebo over 8 weeks; metabolic labs remained stable. [15]

Best for:Mild VMS or as a low-risk add-on.

Caution:High-dose vitamin E can increase bleeding risk; keep to trial-like doses if on anticoagulants.

Tip:Choose natural 'd-alpha' forms; skip megadoses. [15]

#7

Vascular tune-up that also helps sleep

Click to expand details...

#8

Better nights, easier days

Click to expand details...

#9

Food-first VMS support—works for some

Click to expand details...

#10

Two ER-β paths, one capsule

Click to expand details...

Timeline Expectations

Fast Results

  • •ERr 731 (noticeable by week 2–4). [5]
  • •Vitamin E (low risk; 2–4 weeks). [15]
  • •Sage extract (3–4 weeks to symptom drop). [8]

Gradual Benefits

  • •Hop extract (optimize by 6–12 weeks; bone support at ~12 months). [11][12]
  • •S-equol (builds by 8–12 weeks). [4]
  • •Pycnogenol (4–12 weeks; sleep/fatigue gains accrue). [16]

Combination Strategies

Rapid Relief VMS Stack

Components: ERr 731 (4 mg AM) + S‑equol (10 mg AM) + Vitamin E (200 IU with lunch)

Targets ER-β via two distinct ligands (rhaponticin derivatives + equol) plus a low-risk antioxidant nudge; different mechanisms, non-overlapping doses. [2][4][15]

Take ERr 731 and S‑equol with breakfast daily; add Vitamin E at lunch. Reassess at 8–12 weeks. If breast cancer history, clear with your oncologist first.

Sleep & Night‑Sweat Stack

Components: Sage extract (thujone‑free) + Melatonin (1–3 mg) + Ashwagandha (300 mg with dinner)

Sage reduces sweating/flash severity; melatonin restores circadian signaling; ashwagandha lowers arousal—together improve sleep continuity and perceived VMS burden. [8][22][13]

Sage in the morning; ashwagandha with dinner; melatonin 30–60 min before bed. Trial for 4–8 weeks.

Bone‑Minded VMS Stack

Components: Hop extract (100 μg 8‑PN) + Calcium (1,000–1,200 mg/day from diet + supplement) + Vitamin D3 (1,000–2,000 IU)

8-PN hop extract reduced VMS in RCTs and showed favorable BMD trajectories when layered on Ca/D over 48 weeks. [11][12]

Daily hop extract with breakfast; split calcium doses (e.g., 500 mg with meals), add D3. Reassess BMD per clinician.

Shopping Guide

Form Matters

  • •Sage: choose thujone-free ethanolic extracts; avoid essential oils for internal use. [8]
  • •Hops: label must state 8-PN microgram content (e.g., 100 μg/day). [11]
  • •S-equol: look for 'S-equol' (not generic isoflavones) at 10 mg/serving. [4]
  • •Soy isoflavones: ensure ≥18–25 mg genistein aglycone per daily dose. [6]
  • •Vitamin E: use natural d-alpha-tocopherol at RCT-like doses (200 IU BID). [15]

Quality Indicators

  • •Third-party testing (USP, NSF, Informed Choice).
  • •Standardized actives listed (e.g., '8-PN 100 μg', 'S-equol 10 mg').
  • •Clinical-dose parity with cited trials.

Avoid

  • •Proprietary blends hiding 20+ herbs—dosing guesswork = poor odds.
  • •Liver-risk botanicals without quality testing (e.g., some black cohosh products). [19]
  • •Labels lacking standardization (no 8-PN, genistein, or S-equol amounts).
  • •'Works in 48 hours' claims—most trials show 2–8 week timelines.

Overrated Options

These supplements are often marketed for menopause but have limited evidence:

Black cohosh

Cochrane review: no significant benefit over placebo for hot flashes or global scores; safety inconsistencies. [19]

Omega‑3 for hot flashes

Large MsFLASH RCT: no improvement vs placebo in VMS frequency or bother despite adequate EPA/DHA dosing. [26]

Magnesium for hot flashes

Well-powered, double-blind RCT showed no benefit vs placebo; more diarrhea on magnesium oxide. [28]

Important Considerations

If you have or had estrogen-sensitive cancer, are on anticoagulants, or take multiple meds, clear any phytoestrogen or high-dose antioxidant with your clinician. Start one product at a time, track symptoms, and stop if you notice headaches, GI upset, rashes, or mood changes. Supplements can interact with prescription therapies and aren't substitutes for hormone therapy, which remains the most effective VMS treatment. [1]

How we chose these supplements

We prioritized placebo-controlled human trials and meta-analyses focused on vasomotor symptoms (VMS) and validated scales (MRS, KMI, WHQ). We weighted effect size and practicality (dose, availability), then sanity-checked against the 2023 Menopause Society nonhormone guidance (which does not recommend supplements for VMS overall), highlighting where newer or niche RCTs show promise. [1]

Common Questions

What supplement works fastest for hot flashes?

ERr 731 often reduces flash number/severity within 2–4 weeks; hop 8-PN shows benefits by ~6 weeks. [5][11]

Are phytoestrogens safe with a history of breast cancer?

Data are mixed; major guidelines are cautious. Discuss any phytoestrogen (equol/soy/hops) with your oncologist first. [1]

Do omega‑3s help hot flashes?

No—large RCTs found no benefit vs placebo for VMS frequency or bother. [26][27]

Can I just drink soy milk?

Food-first is fine, but response varies; if no change after 12 weeks, switch to S-equol. [6][4]

How long should I trial a supplement?

Give 8–12 weeks at the studied dose before you judge; track daily flashes and sleep.

Sources

  1. 1.
    The 2023 nonhormone therapy position statement of The North American Menopause Society (2023) [link]
  2. 2.
    Efficacy of Rheum rhaponticum extract (ERr 731) on menopause symptoms: systematic review & meta-analysis (2024) [link]
  3. 3.
    ERr 731 in perimenopausal women: 12‑week randomized, double‑blind, placebo‑controlled trial (2006) [link]
  4. 4.
    Equol decreases hot flashes: systematic review & meta‑analysis of RCTs (2018) [link]
  5. 5.
    S‑equol vs isoflavones pilot RCT on hot flash frequency (2012) [link]
  6. 6.
    Soy isoflavones reduce hot flashes: systematic review & meta‑analysis of RCTs (2012) [link]
  7. 7.
    Isoflavone supplementation and menopausal symptoms: updated systematic review & meta‑analysis (2022) [link]
  8. 8.
    Thujone‑free Salvia officinalis extract: double‑blind RCT in menopausal women (2021) [link]
  9. 9.
    ClinicalTrials.gov registry: Sage extract 3,400 mg (DER 1:17), 12 weeks (2014) [link]
  10. 10.
    First clinical evidence for sage in menopausal hot flushes (open trial) (2011) [link]
  11. 11.
    Standardized hop extract (8‑PN) RCT for menopausal complaints (2005) [link]
  12. 12.
    8‑PN hop extract: 1‑year RCT on bone health in osteopenic postmenopausal women (2023) [link]
  13. 13.
    Ashwagandha root extract for perimenopausal symptoms: randomized double‑blind placebo‑controlled study (2021) [link]
  14. 14.
    Pycnogenol improves hair density in menopausal women: randomized placebo‑controlled trial (2023) [link]
  15. 15.
    Curcumin and vitamin E trial in postmenopausal women (2022) [link]
  16. 16.
    Low‑dose Pycnogenol in 170 perimenopausal women: randomized double‑blind placebo‑controlled (2013) [link]
  17. 17.
    Randomized double‑blind placebo‑controlled Pycnogenol trial (~200 women) (2007) [link]
  18. 18.
    Review of Pycnogenol human RCTs (Frontiers in Nutrition) (2024) [link]
  19. 19.
    Cochrane Review: Black cohosh for menopausal symptoms (2012) [link]
  20. 20.
    S‑equol sampling trial + prevalence of equol producers (~20–30% U.S.) (2019) [link]
  21. 21.
    Combined soy + hop extract: 12‑week randomized double‑blind placebo‑controlled trial (2021) [link]
  22. 22.
    Melatonin in menopausal women: systematic review & meta‑analysis of RCTs (2021) [link]
  23. 23.
    Melatonin levels across menopause (Menopause journal) (2014) [link]
  24. 24.
    Melatonin reduces climacteric symptoms: double‑blind RCT (2015) [link]
  25. 25.
    Melatonin effects on depression/anxiety in postmenopause: meta‑analysis of RCTs (2023) [link]
  26. 26.
    MsFLASH RCT: Omega‑3 vs placebo—no VMS benefit (2013) [link]
  27. 27.
    Omega‑3 RCT abstract (Menopause journal) (2014) [link]
  28. 28.
    Magnesium oxide RCT for hot flashes—no benefit (2014) [link]

This content is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice. Always consult healthcare providers before starting supplements. We cite research but errors may exist. Report an error