Top 8 Evidence-Based Recommendations
We read 30+ meta-analyses and randomized trials on hypertrophy and strength—then ranked by effect size, safety, cost, and practicality. No affiliate picks. Just what grows muscle, dose by dose.
Quick Reference Card
Show all 8 supplements...
Ranked Recommendations
#1Top Choice
The one that actually adds reps, loads, and lean mass
Dose: 3–5 g daily (optional load: 20 g/day split for 5–7 days, then 3–5 g/day)
Time to Effect: 7–28 days (as muscles saturate)
How It Works
Boosts phosphocreatine to recycle ATP so you can do more hard reps; repeated higher training volume drives hypertrophy. Also draws water into muscle cells, a growth-friendly signal. [1]
Evidence
Multiple RCTs and recent meta-analyses show creatine + lifting increases lean mass and regional hypertrophy versus placebo; long-term use is well supported and safe. [1]
Best for:Anyone lifting 2–5+ days/week; vegetarians/vegans often see bigger bumps
Caution:Benign water-weight increase; hydrate. No proven kidney harm in healthy people—if you have kidney disease, ask your clinician first. [1]
Tip:Monohydrate is king—other forms (HCl, nitrate, buffered) aren't superior for gains. Take with carbs/protein if you want, but timing isn't critical. [^17^18^19]
#2Strong Alternative
Hit your daily protein target—consistently
Dose: 20–40 g per serving; total daily protein ~1.6–2.2 g/kg (in 3–5 meals)
Time to Effect: Weeks (as lean mass accrues with training)
How It Works
Provides essential amino acids—especially leucine—to trigger mTOR and muscle protein synthesis; repeat stimulations build muscle. [^2^3]
Evidence
Meta-analysis: protein supplementation augments resistance-training gains in lean mass, with diminishing returns beyond ~1.6 g/kg/day. ISSN position stand supports 1.4–2.0 g/kg/day for lifters. [^2^3]
Best for:People who under-eat protein or want convenient post-workout nutrition
Caution:Dairy sensitivities—use whey isolate or a quality EAA/vegan blend
Tip:Pre-sleep casein (30–40 g) can boost overnight MPS; spread 20–40 g protein doses every 3–4 h. [3]
#3Worth Considering
The minimalist way to flip the 'build muscle' switch
Dose: 5–10 g around training (aim ≥2–3 g leucine per dose)
Time to Effect: Minutes for MPS; weeks for visible gains
How It Works
EAAs—especially leucine—activate mTOR and MPS even when total calories are low; unlike BCAAs alone, EAAs supply all building blocks. [^3^12]
Evidence
Human trials show LEAA/EAA acutely stimulate MPS; leucine alone or BCAAs alone are inferior for hypertrophy over time versus complete protein/EAA. [^3^12^15]
Best for:Cutting phases, low-appetite days, or dairy-free lifters needing leucine-rich hits
Caution:May taste bitter; can affect blood sugar meds—check with your clinician
Tip:If your protein meal is small, add 5 g EAA to reach the leucine threshold (~2–3 g). [3]
#4
Small strength boost, joint-friendly recovery—especially if older
Dose: 1–3 g/day combined EPA+DHA with meals
Time to Effect: 8–12 weeks
How It Works
Incorporates into muscle cell membranes, potentially enhancing anabolic signaling and reducing inflammation, aiding strength adaptations. [4]
Evidence
Recent meta-analysis: omega-3 + resistance training improves strength (small effect), with mixed effects on muscle mass—benefits clearer in older adults. [^4^5]
Best for:Lifters 40+ or with low fish intake; cutting phases with achy joints
Caution:May increase bleeding risk with anticoagulants—ask your clinician
Tip:Pair fish oil with your highest-fat meal for absorption; keep capsules refrigerated to reduce fish burps.
#5
Squeeze extra reps today to grow tomorrow
Dose: 6–8 g 40–60 min pre‑workout
Time to Effect: Single workout (acute)
How It Works
Raises arginine and nitric oxide to improve blood flow and ammonia clearance, delaying fatigue so you complete more quality reps/sets. [^6^7^8]
Evidence
Meta-analyses: small but significant increase in reps to failure in strength training; no direct strength increase, but more training volume is a realistic hypertrophy lever. [^6^7^8]
Best for:High-volume push/pull/legs days; pump-chasers
Caution:Some GI upset at full doses—split 4 g + 4 g if needed
Tip:Works best on multi-set, near-failure sessions at 60–80% 1RM. [6]
#6
Adaptogen with legit strength and size data
Dose: 300 mg root extract (KSM‑66 or equivalent) twice daily
Time to Effect: 6–8 weeks
How It Works
May reduce exercise stress and modestly raise androgens, supporting harder training and recovery—netting more strength/size. [9]
Evidence
Double-blind RCT in novice lifters: +strength, +muscle size, -body fat vs placebo over 8 weeks. More trials needed, but signal is promising. [9]
Best for:High-stress lifters or beginners starting structured programs
Caution:Autoimmune/thyroid issues or sedatives—consult your clinician first
Tip:Take with meals to limit GI upset; pair with creatine for complementary mechanisms.
#7
Not a mass builder—unless you're low
#8
Cutting and detraining insurance—not a mass driver in trained lifters
Timeline Expectations
Fast Results
- •Creatine monohydrate
- •Citrulline malate pre-workout
Gradual Benefits
- •Protein to 1.6–2.2 g/kg/day
- •Omega-3 EPA/DHA
- •Vitamin D (if deficient)
Combination Strategies
The Big 3 Growth Stack
Components: Creatine monohydrate 3–5 g/day + Whey or 20–40 g protein per meal + Citrulline malate 6–8 g pre‑workout
Creatine increases training capacity over weeks; whey ensures you hit the ~1.6 g/kg/day protein sweet spot; citrulline adds reps today—together they maximize volume and recovery, the two biggest hypertrophy levers. [^1^2^6]
Daily: creatine anytime. Training days: whey within 2 h pre/post; citrulline 40–60 min pre.
Masters (40+) Strength Saver
Components: Omega‑3 (EPA/DHA) 2–3 g/day + Protein to 1.6–2.2 g/kg/day + Vitamin D to repletion if low
In older adults, omega-3s show small strength benefits; adequate protein is essential; correcting low vitamin D supports function. [^4^2^10^11]
Daily with meals. Test 25(OH)D and adjust vitamin D dose; keep protein evenly spaced.
Stress‑Resilient Gains
Components: Ashwagandha 300 mg twice daily + Creatine 3–5 g/day + EAA 5–10 g on low‑protein meals
Ashwagandha can improve training quality under stress; creatine boosts output; EAAs ensure MPS when appetite or time is tight. [^9^1^3]
Ashwagandha with breakfast/dinner; creatine anytime; EAAs pre‑ or post‑lift when meals are small.
Shopping Guide
Form Matters
- •Creatine: monohydrate only (micronized mixes easier); other forms aren't better for gains.
- •Protein: whey isolate for lactose-sensitive; casein for pre-sleep; vegan blends need added leucine to hit ~2–3 g per serving.
- •Omega-3: choose triglyceride/re-esterified TG forms with ≥500 mg EPA + 500 mg DHA per 2 capsules.
- •Citrulline: look for 2:1 citrulline:malate ratio or pure L-citrulline (6–8 g achieves similar arginine).
- •Ashwagandha: standardized root extract (e.g., ≥5% withanolides), avoid proprietary blends without assays.
Quality Indicators
- •Third-party tested (NSF Certified for Sport, Informed Choice).
- •Transparent labels with exact mg/g amounts.
- •Batch/lot testing and contaminant screens (heavy metals, microbes).
Avoid
- •'Proprietary blends' hiding doses.
- •Claims of 'creatine HCl is 38× better'—no performance advantage over monohydrate.
- •Mega-dose vitamin D without blood testing.
- •BCAAs marketed as a 'muscle builder'—they're incomplete; choose EAA or protein instead.
Overrated Options
These supplements are often marketed for muscle growth but have limited evidence:
BCAAs (alone)
May reduce soreness markers but don't build muscle like EAAs or protein because they lack the full amino acid set needed for MPS and hypertrophy. [^12^14]
Beta‑alanine
Great for high-intensity performance, but meta-analysis shows no effect on fat-free mass or body fat—so not a hypertrophy supplement. [20]
Glutamine
Human RCTs in lifters show no significant benefit for strength or lean mass versus placebo. Save it for clinical needs. [^23^26]
Important Considerations
Supplements complement—don't replace—progressive overload, sleep, and calories. If you're pregnant, have kidney/liver/thyroid/bleeding disorders, or take anticoagulants, consult your clinician before use. Choose third-party tested products to avoid contamination.
How we chose these supplements
We prioritized meta-analyses and RCTs in trained adults where available, ranking by effect size on lean mass/strength, evidence quality, safety, cost, and practicality. Key anchors: creatine and protein position/meta-analyses; targeted reviews for omega-3, citrulline, vitamin D, HMB; and RCTs for ashwagandha. [^1^2^3^4^6^9^10^13]
Common Questions
What’s the single best supplement for muscle growth?
Creatine monohydrate. It reliably increases training volume/strength and lean mass in lifters at 3–5 g/day. [1]
How much protein do I actually need to grow?
About 1.6–2.2 g/kg/day, split into 20–40 g servings every 3–4 h, each with ~2–3 g leucine. [^2^3]
Are BCAAs worth it for bulking?
No. They may reduce soreness markers, but they don't build muscle like protein or EAA. [^12^14]
Do I need to load creatine?
Loading works faster (20 g/day for 5–7 days), but daily 3–5 g reaches the same saturation in a few weeks. [1]
Which supplements work fast vs slow?
Fast: citrulline (same-day reps), creatine (1–4 weeks). Slow: omega-3, ashwagandha, vitamin D (if low). [^1^4^6^9^10]
Sources
- 1.The Effects of Creatine Supplementation Combined with Resistance Training on Regional Measures of Muscle Hypertrophy: Systematic Review & Meta‑analysis (2023) (2023) [link]
- 2.Protein supplementation + resistance training: meta‑analysis & meta‑regression (Morton 2018) (2018) [link]
- 3.
- 4.
- 5.
- 6.
- 7.
- 8.
- 9.
- 10.
- 11.
- 12.
- 13.
- 14.
- 15.
- 16.
- 17.
- 18.
- 19.
- 20.
- 23.
- 26.