Quality 27 out of 100 · Poor
Spring Valley's quality evidence is mixed and materially weaker than brands with public COAs, USP verification, NSF certification, or disclosed ISO-accredited testing. The most important quality negatives are a December 2023 potential mold recall in one liquid product and older peer-reviewed testing that raised consistency and contamination concerns in sampled herbal products. The evidence should be read proportionally: Spring Valley has hundreds of products, and the strongest negative findings cover a small subset, but the brand also does not provide the independent verification that would offset those concerns.
Not scored: No public batch COA portal, no disclosed ISO 17025 lab program, no full manufacturer list, and no comprehensive product-line audit were found. ConsumerLab full brand report details are mostly behind a membership wall.
How this score was built
Starts at 50, ends at 27.
- −15 Potential mold contamination recall in one Spring Valley liquid product. ConsumerLab reported that BioMylz Pvt. Ltd., the contract manufacturer, recalled 24,324 units of Spring Valley Biotin and Collagen Liquid Natural Berry Flavor on December 1, 2023 due to potential mold contamination. This is one product within a very large line, but contamination is a high-severity quality signal. Base contamination penalty selected at -20, recency 2 to 5 years from July 1, 2026 equals 75 percent, final -15. 1,2,3 December 2023 event, 2 to 5 years old as of July 1, 2026 · 75% weight
- −8 Independent peer-reviewed herbal testing found consistency and contamination concerns in sampled Spring Valley herbal products. The PLOS One study reported significant between-bottle variation for sampled herbal supplements, with Spring Valley Ginger among the least variable samples but Spring Valley Korean Panax Ginseng showing significant differences between bottles in all tests described in the article summary. Because this evidence covers a narrow herbal subset, not the full 443-product Spring Valley line listed in NIH DSLD, I applied a proportional quality penalty: 50 percent of a -20 poor-quality verified finding equals -10, then 75 percent recency weight for a 2021 paper equals -8. 4,5 2021 study, 2 to 5 years old as of July 1, 2026 · 75% weight
- +0 No verified USP or NSF product certification found for Spring Valley in the sources reviewed. USP's current verified-product listing shows other store and national brands such as Nature Made, Kirkland Signature, Member's Mark, Natrol, Nature's Bounty, vitafusion, YouTheory, Culturelle, and others, but Spring Valley was not visible in the reviewed listing. NSF provides searchable official listings for certified dietary supplements, but searches did not surface Spring Valley certified products. Absence of certification is common in the market, so this is documented as context and not penalized. 6,7,8 current directory evidence reviewed in 2026 · full weight

