Quality 66 out of 100 · Mixed
Sundown has above-average manufacturing verification for a budget mass-market brand because NSF lists the Rexall Sundown manufacturing entity under NSF/ANSI 455-2 GMP and multiple products disclose third-party lab testing. The main quality limitations are the lack of public batch COAs, lack of visible USP Verified or NSF Certified for Sport product listings, and older FDA inspection history. The 2008 FDA Form 483 and later VAI classification are discounted for age, but they keep the quality score from reaching a high-trust tier.
Not scored: No batch COA portal, named lab, test method scope, lot-level heavy metal results or customer-service COA response record was found. ConsumerLab's Sundown product result is paywalled, so it was not used as proof of passing or failing.
How this score was built
Starts at 50, ends at 66.
- +14 NSF/ANSI 455-2 GMP facility certification verified. NSF lists NHS U.S., LLC doing business as Solgar, Nature's Bounty, Puritan's Pride and Rexall Sundown under NSF/ANSI 455-2 Good Manufacturing Practices for Dietary Supplements, with multiple listed facilities in Arizona, Florida, New Jersey, New York and Texas. Awarded +14 within the +10 to +15 range because the certification is current and covers a broad manufacturing footprint, but it is facility GMP certification rather than product-level USP Verified or NSF Certified for Sport coverage. 1 Current NSF listing, checked July 2026. · full weight
- +8 Third-party testing is disclosed across sampled retail listings. Sundown product pages and retailer listings repeatedly state that products are third-party lab tested for safety, quality and purity. Awarded +8 within the +8 to +12 range because the claim appears across multiple products, but the brand does not name the lab, publish methods or publish batch COAs. 2,3,4,5 Current or recently crawled product and brand listings. · full weight
- +3 Heavy metal contaminant control is disclosed for fish oil only. Sundown Fish Oil listings state that fish oil is purified to eliminate mercury or heavy metal contaminants. Awarded +3 within the +3 to +6 range because this is product-category specific and not a line-wide public heavy metals program. 26,27 Current or recently crawled product listing and NIH DSLD label data. · full weight
- −4 FDA Form 483 observations from 2008 at NBTY doing business as NBTY Rexall Sundown. FDA's posted 2008 Form 483 for the Boca Raton dietary supplement manufacturer cited cleaning record and hygiene-related observations. Base penalty selected: -15 within the -15 to -25 FDA 483 range because observations related to dietary supplement manufacturing controls. Temporal discount: 10+ years old, 25 percent weight. Calculation: -15 x 0.25 = -3.75, rounded to -4. 6 2008 inspection, more than 10 years old, 25 percent temporal weight. · 25% weight
- −5 FDA inspection classification record indicates a later VAI inspection for Rexall Sundown. A public inspection data mirror reports FDA inspection 800286 for Rexall Sundown Inc. classified as VAI. FDA explains VAI means objectionable conditions were found, but the agency was not prepared to take or recommend administrative or regulatory action. Base penalty selected: -10 at the low end of the -15 to -25 FDA 483 range because VAI is less severe than OAI and no warning letter was found. Temporal discount: 5 to 10 years, 50 percent weight. Calculation: -10 x 0.50 = -5. 7,8 2019 inspection classification, 5 to 10 years old, 50 percent temporal weight. · 50% weight

